Originally from Waterbury, CT, Toby was hired by the East Hartford School District in 2001. He attended Central Connecticut State University and earned a bachelor's degree in Physical Education, a cross endorsement in Health Education, and a master's degree in Educational Technology.
He was assigned to Norris Elementary School for student teaching. In the following years, Toby taught Physical Education at Norris, Mayberry, O'Brien, Silver Lane, and O'Connell. He is currently teaching Health and Physical Education at Sunset Ridge School. In his current role, Toby contributed to the development of the health curriculum for grades 4-6.
He also has experience coaching gymnastics and rugby. He was an assistant coach at Gymnastics Unlimited in Bristol for five years, working with gymnasts between the ages of 8 and 18. He was also the head coach for the CCSU men's rugby team in 2002 when it placed 2nd in nation.